Brought to you by CrossFit 42South and CrossFit Works.

Tuesday 12 July 2011

There are no essential carbohydrates, even for athletes.

By Kurt Harris (Archevore)

WHAT IS YOUR OPINION ON THIS? PLEASE POST TO COMMENTS.

Despite current nutritional dogma dating from the 1970's, carbohydrate consumption is completely unnecessary for your energy (or any other) needs. Fat is the primary way we store energy in our bodies, and eating fat is the evolutionarily preferred food source in a food-abundant environment.* During aerobic exercise, the predominant fuel source is fatty acids, supplemented by glycogen stores.

It is possible to eat no carbohydrates at all and still do plenty of physical work. Any carbohydrates needed not provided from glycogen or food can be produced in abundance via gluconeogenesis. Glucose provided this way makes you literally burn fat, and keeps your insulin levels low.

You have about about an hour or more of exercise in your liver and muscle glycogen.

If you are a lean runner, you have enough energy in your body fat to walk about 800 miles.

You simply don't need to eat carbohydrates to exercise.

Try this:

Once you are adapted to low carb intake (it may take 6 weeks or more, so go slowly) your mitochondria, including in your muscles and your brain, will literally proliferate and be more energy efficient. Gradually start doing your workouts with less and less carb consumption prior to exercise, to the point where you are solely working out in the fasting state. By fasting state I mean no food for at least 12 hours. Now, most people think I am a lunatic when I suggest this, but hear me out.

I have talked about intermittent fasting as a complement to low carb eating to keep your insulin levels low. One reason they are complementary is once you are off the glucose/insulin hormonal yo-yo, your ability to tolerate fasting is increased immeasurably. On a very low carb diet you are literally never hungry, in that desperate way you are when you are carb-dependent. Intermittent fasting is absolutely the best way to keep your insulin levels as low as possible (more on why that is good in the future)

Working up to fasting workouts slowly, and once you have been on a low carbohydrate regimen for several months, you will find that your performance (running time, max lifting) eventually equals or exceeds what you could do before with a meal 2 hours before, as your body becomes more adapted to fatty acid metabolism and less dependent on glucose .

Now here is the good part. When you race, you have new mitochondria and your newly efficient fat-preferring metabolism. Add a moderate carb load and some GU bars if its a long race, and you will be faster than you were before. Glucose is now your nitrous oxide, not your primary fuel.

When you want to climb K2, you train in Leadville, Colorado, where the air is thinnest. Training at 10,000 feet is harder at first but more effective. Same with fasting workouts.



*When food was abundant in paleo times, it was often because there were large mammals rich in fat stores. Humans ate the fat, and it was adaptive for them to be satiated because food was abundant. No insulin response to make them store the fat, just use it for fuel and waste the rest. Conversely, when fruits were available they were much less calorie dense than their modern versions and in many environments only seasonally available. Fructose seems to work the opposite of saturated fat - the hormonal signal to the body is to store it and keep eating more. That may be why fructose is sent straight to the liver to be converted into triglycerides. Eating lots of high density fructose-laden food year-round in a food abundant environment is not something we are adapted to. The paleo enviroment we need to emulate is the one metabolically closest to our current condition of food abundance - high fat consumption.

6 comments:

  1. Leandra here

    Sounds sensible but i love my fruit too much to put it to the test!

    I've enjoyed and learnt from everyone posting what they eat so i thought I'd do the same. I'm not as far along in my journey of clean eating, but I'll post it warts and all....

    Tuesday - Office Day
    6.30am - half a smoothie made with milk, greek yoghurt, 2 eggs and vacola peaches. Black Coffee

    10.00am - rest of smoothie.

    12.00 - Leftover roast lamb with minted yoghurt sauce, lettuce, 2 carrots. Coffee

    3.30 - 'Cup of soup' - vegetable soup made on chicken stock from roast chicken carcass

    6.30 - Dinner at mums house - Mince dish with roast vegetables

    Wednesday - Stay at home mum day

    8am - Eggs and bacon, coffee

    11.30am - mini quiche, birthday cake with blue icing and smarties (oops....next time i go to a bithday party i will eat beforehand)

    1.30pm - 2 pieces of home made jerky, 1 apple,2 carrotts (yum yum)

    6.00pm - sausages and vegetables.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Go Leandra, this is a fantastic list! Your warts are minimal, top effort! Also wanted to congratulate you on your xfitting of late - you were on fire during our team WOD, super burpees and ground to OH. Please keep spreading the word, esp to the folks on Hampden rd (think the prize money is up to 10K!). See you soon :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Catch-up post! I've been slack with posting my intake-oops.

    Mon&Tues intake exactly the same.

    Weds:
    6am: eggs, bacon, garlic butter.
    11am: chicken fingers
    1pm: rest of chicken fingers
    7:30pm sirloin steak, sweet potato chips*

    Thurs:
    7am: eggs, bacon, avocado
    11:30am-2pm: chicken fingers, small amount of pumpkin and sweet potato soup
    8pm: sirloin steak, sweet potato chips*

    *Sweet potato 'chips' were sweet potato cut up into... 'chip-like' shapes and baked in the oven... I say 'chip-like' because there were, uh, interesting to say the least..

    Smaller intake lately, I think a lot of it has to do with work stress. Today's intake sucked because I was rushing around like crazy while my co-worker was awol so ate during the few 'quiet' moments. Lots of stress and lots of students needing help (gas leak at work, blah, blah, STRESS!) but felt much better after tonight's WOD.

    Looking forward to tomorrow night's nutrition talk and dinner. Hope to see you guys there!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jose here.

    I love that you’ve posted this! I have been experimenting with this very thing for the last week. I’m doing 16/8 IF - were 16 hours in a fasted state and an 8 hour feed window. It is a little difficult at first because you are conscious of the fact you can’t eat, and it’s not necessarily because you are hungry it's just knowing you can’t eat. But it does get easier. I also wouldn’t recommend it until you got your carb cravings under control.

    Its a bit early to post performance results, however I did just train Brazilian Jiu Jitsu in a fasted state and felt pretty strong and didn’t lack energy.

    There is a pretty good site that talks a lot about Intermittent fasting, if anyone is interested you can have a look at: http://www.leangains.com/

    Cheers.

    ReplyDelete